Interaction between seed size and NaCl on germination and early seedling growth of some Turkish cultivars of chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.)

Interaction between seed size and NaCl on germination and early seedling growth of some Turkish cultivars of chickpea ( Cicer arietinum L.) 1 first-author 2 2 3 4 4 corresp ‡Corresponding Author ‡Corresponding Author †E-mail:kmkhawar@gmail.com †E-mail:kmkhawar@gmail.com kmkhawar@gmail.com 4 Department of Field Crops, Faculty of Agriculture, Suleyman Demirel University, 32260 Isparta, Turkey Department of Field Crops, Faculty of Agriculture, Suleyman Demirel University, 32260 Isparta, Turkey Central Research Institute for Field Crops, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, 06171 Yenimahalle, Ankara, Turkey Central Research Institute for Field Crops, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, 06171 Yenimahalle, Ankara, Turkey Department of Field Crops, Faculty of Agriculture, Mustafa Kemal University, 31040 Hatay, Turkey Department of Field Crops, Faculty of Agriculture, Mustafa Kemal University, 31040 Hatay, Turkey Department of Field Crops, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Ankara, 06110 Diskapi, Ankara, Turkey Department of Field Crops, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Ankara, 06110 Diskapi, Ankara, Turkey Chickpea is an important food legume crop of Turkey and is largely grown for human consumption on low moisture or salt-affected soils. The objective of the study was to find the effects of NaCl stress at electrical conductivities of 4.5, 8.6, 12.7 and 16.3 dS/m and seed sizes (7, 8 and 9 mm) on germination and early seedling growth of three popular chickpea cultivars (AKN-97, Gokce and Uzunlu-99). Mean frequency of germination, germination time, germination index, root length, shoot length and seedling fresh weight showed seed size-dependent responses of cultivars to salt stress. In general, small seeds germinated and grew more rapidly compared to medium and large seeds of the same cultivars against all levels of salt stress, with the best results in cultivar Uzunlu-99. No effect of NaCl treatments was observed on frequency of germination; however, a drastic decrease in early seedling growth was recorded at increased NaCl concentrations. Regression analysis results showed a significantly positive relationship ( P < 0.01) between seed size and mean germination time, whereas a significantly negative relationship was recorded between seed size and germination index, root length, shoot length. Moreover, linear regression values apparently confirmed that increased seed size in each cultivar affected decreased germination index, root and shoot lengths with enhanced mean germination time. Thus, it was concluded that the use of small seeds could considerably reduce the production costs of chickpea in salt-affected soils. Chickpea ( Cicer arietinum L.) NaCl stress Cultivar Seed size Germination INTRODUCTION 1 Chickpea ( Cicer arietinum L.) is an annual grain legume that is used extensively for human consumption in Turkey. Chickpea is classified into ‘desi’ and ‘kabuli’ types based primarily on seed color. Desi chickpea has a pigmented (tan to black) seed coat and small seed size ( > 100 seeds/28.47 g). Kabuli chickpea has white to cream-colored seed coat and ranges in size from small to large ( > 100 to < 50 seeds/28.47 g) (Miller et al., 2002 2002 ). Chickpea is largely grown on low moisture soils of Anatolia where evaporation exceeds precipitation, resulting in salt accumulation on the soil surface (Meiri, 1984 1984 ; Pessarakli, 1999 1999 ). There are conflicting reports on the effects of salinity on seed germination and growth in chickpea and many other species and cultivars (Bliss et al., 1986 1986 ; Hampson and Simpson, 1990 1990 ). However, it could not be determined clearly that differences between cultivars against salt tolerance are mainly due to genetic or morphologic factors. Soltani et al.( 2002 2002 ) proposed that large seeds had an advantage in producing more vigorous chickpea seedlings under saline or non-saline conditions. Gan et al.( 2003 2003 ) indicated that the use of small seeds and shallow planting reduced the production costs without reduction in seed yield. Although chickpea, like other legumes, is largely salt sensitive (Mass and Hoffman, 1977 1977 ; Lauter and Munns, 1986 1986 ; Ashraf and Waheed, 1993 1993 ; Özdemir and Engin, 1994 1994 ; Welfare et al., 2002 2002 ; Ozcan et al., 2000 2000 ), there are significant differences among chickpea cultivars against salt tolerance during germination. However, Kheradnam and Ghorashy ( 1973 1973 ) recorded relatively small differences among four Iranian chickpea cultivars in their germination response to NaCl and tolerance to salinity. While Goel and Varshney ( 1987 1987 ) and Yadav et al.( 1989 1989 ) agreed that germination of chickpea is relatively less affected by salinity than subsequent early seedling growth, Kumar ( 1985 1985 ) emphasized that later growth stages of chickpea are more sensitive to salt stress compared to earlier growth stages. The plants flower profusely with indeterminate growth habit, and continue to flower and set pods as long as climatic conditions are favorable. This results in seeds of different sizes even in the same variety as they are composed of seed mixtures extracted from early, middle or late pollinating flowers with wide range of variation in chickpea seed size (Upadhyaya, 2003 2003 ). Variation in seed size is associated with geographical effects on genetic factors, irregular flowering, number of seeds per pod, and number of pods per plant (Pedersen et al., 1961 1961 ; Smithson et al., 1985 1985 ; Miller et al., 2002 2002 ). The seeds of chickpea cultivars differ in several respects including size, color and shape. Two loci B and F r are responsible for changes in seed size and shape. However, their effects are modified by combination of factors including rainfall, temperature and number of seeds per pod (Smithson et al., 1985 1985 ). The aim of the study was to investigate the influence of salt stress on factors affecting germination of seeds with different sizes from three Turkish chickpea cultivars. MATERIALS AND METHODS 1 The seeds of Uzunlu-99, Gokce and AKN-97 (kabuli type) were obtained from Central Field Crops Research Institute, Ankara, Turkey, with mean protein percentages of 19.91%, 25.30% and 23.12%, respectively. They were separated into small (7 mm), medium (8 mm) and large (9 mm) sized seeds by passing through a series of sieves. The 100-seed weights of three cultivars are shown in Table 1 1 . Data represent mean± SD of four replicates; LSD =1.42 ( P < 0.05) 2 Seed sizes (mm) 3 100-seed weight (g) AKN-97 Gokce Uzunlu-99 7 31.3±0.31 30.9±0.76 32.6±0.16 8 42.6±0.10 40.3±0.18 42.7±0.18 9 50.5±1.45 48.3±0.65 48.7±1.68 NaCl concentrations at electrical conductivities of 4.5, 8.6, 12.7 and 16.3 dS/m were adjusted before the start of the experiment. Distilled water served as a control (0.0 dS/m). Four replicates of 50 seeds for each cultivar (50×4=200 seeds) were germinated between four rolled filter papers with 60 ml of respective test solutions. The papers were replaced every 2 d to prevent accumulation of salts (Rehman et al., 1996 1996 ). Each rolled paper was placed in a sealed polythene bag to prevent evaporation. Seeds were allowed to germinate at (20±1) °C in the dark for 10 d. A seed was considered to be germinated when the emerging radicle elongated to 2 mm. Germination percentage was recorded every 24 h for 10 d. Mean germination time (MGT) was calculated for the rate of germination (Ellis and Roberts, 1980 1980 ) with the following formula: MGT =∑( fx )/∑ f , where f is the number of newly germinated seeds on each day and x is days of counting. Germination index (GI) was calculated by the method of Wang et al.( 2004 2004 ) with the formula as following: GI =∑( G i / T t ), where G i is the germination percentage at the i th day, and T t is days of germination test. The higher GI results show the higher seed quality and better performance (Wang et al., 2004 2004 ). Root and shoot lengths and seedling fresh weight were measured on the 10th day. Ten grams of seeds respectively from each seed size and cultivar were placed in Petri dishes containing distilled water to determine water uptake of seeds necessary for germination. The water uptake was measured as fresh weight percentage increase in seed weight. The experiment was designed with 3 factors and arranged at random. The first factor was cultivars (Uzunlu-99, Gokce and AKN-97), the second was seed sizes (7, 8 and 9 mm), and the third was different NaCl solution levels (0.0, 4.5, 8.6, 12.7 and 16.3 dS/m). Data given in percentages were subjected to arcsine transformation before statistical analysis. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) for all investigated parameters and linear regression analysis to investigate the effect of seed size on investigated parameters were performed by using the MSTAT-C computer software, version 2.10 (Michigan State University, USA). Significant differences among means were compared by LSD test ( P < 0.05). RESULTS 1 Water uptake was significantly ( P < 0.05) affected by the interaction between cultivars and seed size, with variable behavior in the three cultivars (Fig. 1 1 ). The small, medium and large seeds of Uzunlu-99 uptook 41.5%, 61.5% and 74.9% water before germination, respectively. This showed that increase in seed size of Uzunlu-99 was accompanied by corresponding increase in the water uptake to germinate seeds. Contrarily, the small, medium and large seeds of Gokce utilized 61.7%, 55.8% and 69.99% water, respectively, and the small, medium and large seeds of AKN-97 used 70.8%, 65.6% and 71.9% water, respectively. Importantly, the medium seeds of both Gokce and AKN-97 needed less water compared to small and large seeds to germinate. Moreover, the amount of water needed to germinate small and large seeds of AKN-97 was similar, whereas the amount of water needed to germinate small and large seeds of Gokce varied significantly. LSD =7.03 ( P < 0.05) NaCl solutions had no effect on frequency of germination, and 100% germination was observed under all NaCl treatments (data not shown). A significant 3-way interaction (cultivar×seed size×NaCl level) was observed for all other investigated characters ( P < 0.05, df =90). MGT increased with each increase in NaCl stress and seed size in all cultivars. The small seeds (7 mm) of AKN-97, Gokce and Uzunlu-99 took the minimum MGT to germinate under all salt stress conditions. Contrarily, the large seeds (9 mm) of three cultivars took the maximum MGT to germinate under all salt stress conditions in general (Table 2 2 ). Data represent mean± SD of four replicates; LSD =0.34 ( P < 0.05, df =90) 2 Cultivars 2 Seed sizes (mm) 5 MGT (d) 0.0 dS/m 4.5 dS/m 8.6 dS/m 12.7 dS/m 16.3 dS/m AKN-97 7 2.88±0.19 2.90±0.10 3.30±0.10 3.80±0.09 3.87±0.13 8 3.22±0.23 3.48±0.08 3.37±0.03 3.90±0.25 4.12±0.24 9 3.53±0.40 3.62±0.20 3.72±0.15 4.62±0.50 4.62±0.50 Gokce 7 2.32±0.12 2.64±0.13 2.83±0.13 2.98±0.18 3.72±0.13 8 2.93±0.20 3.12±0.06 3.52±0.25 3.52±0.31 4.07±0.20 9 3.13±0.33 3.45±0.22 4.30±0.44 3.98±0.32 4.88±0.15 Uzunlu-99 7 2.75±0.17 2.57±0.13 3.16±0.24 2.82±0.13 3.83±0.08 8 2.98±0.08 2.98±0.13 3.80±0.01 3.10±0.09 4.20±0.05 9 3.33±0.34 3.50±0.22 3.50±0.05 3.88±0.12 4.45±0.36 GI was significantly affected by NaCl and seed size. Small seeds of all cultivars gave the highest GI values at all NaCl concentrations, while increasing NaCl concentration reduced GI variably (Table 3 3 ). Small seeds of Uzunlu-99 gave higher GI at both 4.5 and 8.6 dS/m compared to the control (0.0 dS/m). Data represent mean± SD of four replicates; LSD =3.82 ( P < 0.05, df =90) 2 Cultivars 2 Seed sizes (mm) 5 GI 0.0 dS/m 4.5 dS/m 8.6 dS/m 12.7 dS/m 16.3 dS/m AKN-97 7 25.0±0.01 25.0±0.00 18.9±1.96 18.1±1.96 17.8±1.90 8 23.3±2.42 23.3±2.42 20.0±0.01 18.1±1.96 16.6±0.01 9 20.0±0.01 20.0±0.00 18.9±1.90 13.9±1.04 15.3±0.01 Gokce 7 33.3±0.01 26.1±1.96 20.0±0.01 25.0±0.01 20.0±0.01 8 25.0±0.01 21.7±1.91 18.9±1.96 25.0±0.01 16.7±0.01 9 23.3±2.42 20.6±2.42 17.8±1.90 17.0±1.96 13.7±1.04 Uzunlu-99 7 23.3±2.42 25.0±0.01 27.7±2.42 23.3±2.42 15.3±1.04 8 23.3±2.82 25.0±0.01 20.0±0.01 20.0±0.01 17.8±1.90 9 20.0±0.01 20.6±2.42 18.1±1.96 18.1±1.91 12.1±1.04 Increased NaCl concentration decreased root length of all cultivars; however, this decrease was more prominent with large seeds (9 mm) of respective cultivars. Small seeds (7 mm) gave the longest roots at control (Table 4 4 ). Increased seed size and salt concentration caused corresponding decreases in root length in all cultivars. The longest roots were obtained from small seeds in each cultivar under all salt stress conditions. Data represent mean± SD of four replicates; LSD =1.29 ( P < 0.05, df =90) 2 Cultivars 2 Seed sizes (mm) 5 Root length (cm) 0.0 dS/m 4.5 dS/m 8.6 dS/m 12.7 dS/m 16.3 dS/m AKN-97 7 11.27±0.90 9.57±0.06 7.57±0.32 5.83±0.72 3.80±0.35 8 9.77±0.32 7.37±0.21 7.17±0.61 4.83±0.20 3.47±0.35 9 9.93±0.68 7.70±0.91 4.83±0.61 3.77±0.58 2.57±0.37 Gokce 7 11.77±0.76 9.17±1.11 7.33±0.06 5.27±0.32 3.63±0.40 8 10.03±0.95 8.60±0.57 7.60±0.70 4.03±0.25 2.57±0.31 9 6.73±1.42 10.13±0.70 6.07±0.66 4.13±0.15 2.43±0.21 Uzunlu-99 7 11.37±0.83 11.27±0.06 8.37±0.81 5.83±0.69 3.13±0.43 8 10.27±0.40 9.70±0.72 5.33±0.81 4.57±0.46 2.73±0.05 9 9.97±0.63 8.43±0.55 6.80±0.26 4.43±0.38 2.97±0.47 The longest shoots were obtained from Uzunlu-99 on small seeds (7 mm) under all NaCl concentrations. Shoot length was severely influenced by salt stress with complete inhibition and no shoots at NaCl stress of 16.3 dS/m in all cultivars (Table 5 5 ). Medium and large seeds of Gokce and large seeds of AKN-97 also failed to develop shoots at NaCl stress of 12.7 dS/m. The results further show that small seeds were superior to medium and large ones at NaCl stresses of 4.5 to 12.7 dS/m. Data represent mean± SD of four replicates; −: Data could not be taken due to no shoot growth; LSD =0.78 ( P < 0.05, df =90) 2 Cultivars 2 Seed sizes (mm) 5 Shoot length (cm) 0.0 dS/m 4.5 dS/m 8.6 dS/m 12.7 dS/m 16.3 dS/m AKN-97 7 5.23±0.80 3.70±0.30 2.60±0.26 1.33±0.15 − 8 4.60±0.35 2.93±0.25 1.97±0.20 1.17±0.17 − 9 4.30±0.62 2.40±0.20 1.40±0.01 − − Gokce 7 4.37±0.67 2.83±0.04 2.33±0.05 1.40±0.10 − 8 4.57±0.15 2.97±0.25 1.40±0.04 − − 9 2.43±0.30 2.30±0.26 1.10±0.20 − − Uzunlu-99 7 6.37±0.47 5.63±0.30 3.30±0.31 1.93±0.16 − 8 5.30±0.44 4.37±0.75 1.23±0.19 1.03±0.10 − 9 4.33±0.55 2.20±0.10 1.27±0.15 1.00±0.10 − As no shoot growth was recorded in the medium and large seeds of Gokce and large seeds of AKN-97 at NaCl stress of 12.7 dS/m and all seeds of all cultivars at NaCl stress of 16.3 dS/m, therefore their root growth was evaluated as seedling fresh weight (Table 6 6 ). Compared to control, each increase in NaCl concentration and seed size resulted in remarkable decrease in seedling fresh weight for all cultivars. Although seed sizes had different responses to each NaCl concentration, the highest seedling fresh weight (71.2 mg/plant) was observed from medium seeds of Uzunlu-99 (control). Data represent mean± SD of four replicates; LSD =6.42 ( P < 0.05, df =90) 2 Cultivars 2 Seed sizes (mm) 5 Seedling fresh weight (mg/plant) 0.0 dS/m 4.5 dS/m 8.6 dS/m 12.7 dS/m 16.3 dS/m AKN-97 7 60.3±5.16 38.3±3.33 32.9±1.07 24.7±1.58 15.9±1.54 8 60.5±2.85 35.9±2.72 30.5±3.06 24.3±1.08 19.4±1.86 9 54.7±3.25 38.9±3.09 23.1±1.57 16.8±1.82 12.5±1.03 Gokce 7 61.2±4.31 44.2±1.97 30.1±0.87 22.1±2.25 8.8±0.56 8 62.3±2.52 44.1±3.82 23.4±2.36 20.6±2.24 10.0±1.01 9 65.3±2.24 34.0±3.45 25.0±2.84 20.7±1.73 10.7±0.98 Uzunlu-99 7 52.1±7.04 37.9±2.95 27.7±1.85 23.8±1.93 15.7±1.65 8 71.2±3.78 44.8±3.49 32.2±3.01 17.0±0.92 11.4±1.15 9 48.1±4.38 45.8±2.81 27.6±2.09 16.7±1.31 11.4±0.79 Linear regression analysis results showed non-significant relationship between seed size and germination percentage or seedling fresh weight (data not given). However, a significantly positive relationship ( P < 0.01) was recorded between seed size and mean germination time, whereas a significantly negative relationship was recorded between seed size and GI, root and shoot lengths (Table 7 7 ). Linear regression values confirmed that increased seed size apparently resulted in decreased GI, root and shoot lengths with enhanced mean germination time. Relationship between seed size and mean germination time, germination index, root and shoot lengths was significant ( P < 0.01) Characters R 2 Regression equations Mean germination time 0.292 y =0.252+0.404 x Germination index 0.201 y =40.469−2.481 x Root length 0.052 y =13.229−0.809 x Shoot length 0.072 y =6.971−0.603 x DISCUSSION 1 The primary action of osmotic inhibition is retardation of water uptake, which is crucial for germination (Kahn, 1960 1960 ). Seed size affected the water uptake and consequently growth parameters of the investigated cultivars. The effect of salinity stress was more prominent on AKN-97 and Gokce compared to Uzunlu-99. NaCl adversely affected the germination time and early seedling growth of chickpea, but any inhibitory effects of NaCl on germination percentage were not determined. The results of this study are in agreement with the observations of Murillo-Amador et al.( 2002 2002 ) in cowpea and Okcu et al.( 2005 2005 ) in pea. They observed that NaCl did not adversely affect germination percentage but delayed MGT. The lower MGT in control (0.0 dS/m) and reduced MGT in small seeds compared to medium and large seeds of all cultivars under all levels of NaCl stress may be due to more rapid water uptake; different concentration of NaCl may have created an osmotic barrier resulting in inhibition of corresponding water uptake, which is in agreement with Nieman ( 1965 1965 ), Wignarajah et al. ( 1975 1975 ) and Yasseen et al.( 1987 1987 ), who emphasized that NaCl inhibits growth by reducing both cell division and cell enlargement. GI of small seeds of each cultivar was higher compared to medium and large seeds under no stress (0.0 dS/m) or all levels of NaCl stress. Wang et al.( 2004 2004 ) indicated that the GI gave the best results to predict field emergence of Sudan grass. Root length was severely influenced by NaCl stress; however, small seeds produced the longest roots. It is assumed that small seeds absorbed water more rapidly compared to medium and large seeds, which resulted in fast root growth. Contrarily, Soltani et al.( 2002 2002 ) observed that root length was diminished by increasing NaCl concentration. They also noted that large seeds gave longer roots compared to medium and small seeds. It is presumed that the differences could be due to different genotypes used in this study. Shoot growth was more adversely affected by hypocotyl injury due to different levels of NaCl than the root especially at 16.3 dS/m in all cultivars. The results are in agreement with Esechie et al.( 2002 2002 ), who proposed that hypocotyl injury was more severe under saline soils compared to non-saline soils. On the other hand, small seeds exhibited better performance than large seeds. Soltani et al.( 2002 2002 ) found that increasing seed size resulted in decreasing shoot length, while no significant differences were determined for the investigated cultivars in the current study. As a result of decreasing root and shoot lengths, seedling fresh weight decreased under increased NaCl concentrations in all cultivars of chickpea. This study further shows that NaCl had greater inhibitory effects on early seedling growth rather than on germination, in agreement with similar observation in alfalfa (Redmann, 1974 1974 ). It is assumed that reducing cell division and plant growth metabolism induced by accumulation of Na + ion caused changes in ion balances and the imbalance of mineral nutrients resulted in a reduction or an inhibition of plant growth (Mer et al., 2000 2000 ). The linear positive relationship between seed size and mean germination time showed that each increase in salt stress resulted in corresponding increase in the germination time of small, medium and large seeds of three cultivars. The significantly negative relationship between seed size and GI, root and shoot lengths suggested that each increase in NaCl concentration resulted in these inhibitory or toxic effects of NaCl, which was observed only after the start of elongation of radicle. Furthermore, the beneficial effects of small seeds under both saline and non-saline conditions were clearly observed in this study. Small seeds (7 mm) germinated and grew more rapidly under NaCl stress, showing that they could be preferred on salt-infected soils to achieve higher levels of crop yield. It is thus concluded that NaCl had no toxic effect on seed germination; however, it affected early seedling growth negatively. References M Ashraf , A Waheed . Response of some genetically diverse lines of chickpea ( Cicer arietinum L.) to salt . Plant and Soil , 1993 . 154 ( 2 ): 257 - 266 . DOI: 10.1007/BF00012531 http://doi.org/10.1007/BF00012531 . Response of some genetically diverse lines of chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.) to salt RD Bliss , KA Platt-Aloia , WW Thomson . Osmotic sensitivity in relation to salt sensitivity in germinating barley seeds . Plant Cell Environ , 1986 . 9 ( 9 ): 721 - 725 . DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-3040.1986.tb02104.x http://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-3040.1986.tb02104.x . Osmotic sensitivity in relation to salt sensitivity in germinating barley seeds RH Ellis , EH Roberts . PD Hebblethwaite . Towards a Rational Basis for Testing Seed Quality . Seed Production , 1980 . : London Butterworths , 605 - 635 . . Towards a Rational Basis for Testing Seed Quality HA Esechie , A Al-Saidi , S Al-Khanjari . Effect of sodium chloride salinity on seedling emergence in chickpea . Journal of Agronomy and Crop Science , 2002 . 188 ( 3 ): 155 - 160 . DOI: 10.1046/j.1439-037X.2002.00554.x http://doi.org/10.1046/j.1439-037X.2002.00554.x . Effect of sodium chloride salinity on seedling emergence in chickpea YT Gan , PR Miller , CL McDonald . Response of kabuli chickpea to seed size and planting depth . Can J Plant Sci , 2003 . 83 ( 1 ): 39 - 46 . . Response of kabuli chickpea to seed size and planting depth N Goel , KA Varshney . Note on seed germination and early seedling growth of two chickpea varieties under saline conditions . Legume Res , 1987 . 10 ( 1 ): 34 - 36 . . Note on seed germination and early seedling growth of two chickpea varieties under saline conditions CR Hampson , GM Simpson . Effects of temperature, salt and osmotic potential on early growth of wheat ( Triticum aestivum ). I. Germination . Can J Bot , 1990 . 68 ( 3 ): 524 - 528 . DOI: 10.1139/b90-072 http://doi.org/10.1139/b90-072 . Effects of temperature, salt and osmotic potential on early growth of wheat (Triticum aestivum). I. Germination A Kahn . An analysis “dark osmotic inhibition” of germination of lettuce seeds . Plant Physiol , 1960 . 35 ( 1 ): 1 - 7 . 16655298 . An analysis “dark osmotic inhibition” of germination of lettuce seeds M Kheradnam , SR Ghorashy . Salt tolerance of chickpea varieties during germination . Agron J , 1973 . 65 ( 2 ): 329 . Salt tolerance of chickpea varieties during germination D Kumar . Emergence, establishment and seed yield of chickpea as affected by sodicity . Annals of Arid Zone , 1985 . 24 ( 4 ): 334 - 340 . . Emergence, establishment and seed yield of chickpea as affected by sodicity DJ Lauter , DN Munns . Salt resistance of chickpea genotype in solutions salinized with NaCl . Annu Rev Plant Physiol , 1986 . 84 ( 2 ): 455 - 461 . . Salt resistance of chickpea genotype in solutions salinized with NaCl EV Mass , GJ Hoffman . Crop salt tolerance—current assessment . J Irrig Drainage Div ASCE , 1977 . 103 ( 2 ): 115 - 134 . . Crop salt tolerance—current assessment A Meiri . I Shainberg , J Shalhevet . Plant Response to Salinity: Experimental Methodology and Application to the Field . Soil Salinity under Irrigation Processes and Management , 1984 . : Berlin Springer-Verlag , . Plant Response to Salinity: Experimental Methodology and Application to the Field RK Mer , PK Prajith , DH Pandya , AN Pandey . Effect of salts on germination of seeds and growth of young plants of Hordeum vulgare , Triticum aestivum , Cicer arietinum and Brassica juncea . J Agron Crop Sci , 2000 . 185 ( 4 ): 209 - 217 . DOI: 10.1046/j.1439-037x.2000.00423.x http://doi.org/10.1046/j.1439-037x.2000.00423.x . Effect of salts on germination of seeds and growth of young plants of Hordeum vulgare, Triticum aestivum, Cicer arietinum and Brassica juncea P Miller , K McKay , B Jenks , 等 . Growing Chickpea in the Northern Great Plains . 2002 . : Montguide Montan State University, Extension Service , MT200204 AG 3/2002,(Available from: http://www.montana.edu/wwwpb/pubs/mt200204.pdf http://www.montana.edu/wwwpb/pubs/mt200204.pdf ) . Growing Chickpea in the Northern Great Plains B Murillo-Amador , R Lopez-Aguilar , C Kaya , J Larrinaga-Mayoral , A Flores-Hernandez . Comparative effects of NaCl and polyethylene glycol on germination, emergence and seedling growth of cowpea . Journal of Agronomy and Crop Science , 2002 . 188 ( 4 ): 235 - 247 . DOI: 10.1046/j.1439-037X.2002.00563.x http://doi.org/10.1046/j.1439-037X.2002.00563.x . Comparative effects of NaCl and polyethylene glycol on germination, emergence and seedling growth of cowpea RH Nieman . Expansion of bean leaves and its suppression by salinity . Plant Physiol , 1965 . 40 ( 1 ): 156 - 161 . 16656057 . Expansion of bean leaves and its suppression by salinity G Okcu , MD Kaya , M Atak . Effects of salt and drought stresses on germination and seedling growth of pea ( Pisum sativum L.) . Turk J Agric For , 2005 . 29 ( 4 ): 237 - 242 . . Effects of salt and drought stresses on germination and seedling growth of pea (Pisum sativum L.) H Ozcan , MA Turan , O Koc , Y Cikili , S Taban . Growth and variations in proline, sodium, chloride, phosphorus and potassium concentrations of chickpea ( Cicer arietinum L. cvs.) varieties under salinity stress . Turk J Agric For , 2000 . 24 ( 6 ): 649 - 654 . . Growth and variations in proline, sodium, chloride, phosphorus and potassium concentrations of chickpea (Cicer arietinum L. cvs.) varieties under salinity stress S Özdemir , M Engin . Effect of NaCl concentrations on germination and seedling growth in chickpea ( Cicer arietinum L.) . Turk J Agric For , 1994 . 18 ( 3 ): 323 - 328 . . Effect of NaCl concentrations on germination and seedling growth in chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.) MW Pedersen , LG Jones , TH Rogers . A Stefferud . Producing Seeds of the Legumes . Seeds , 1961 . US Department of Agriculture , 171 - 181 . Yearbook . Producing Seeds of the Legumes M Pessarakli . Handbook of Plant and Crop Stress , 1999 . : New York Marcel Decker Inc , . Handbook of Plant and Crop Stress RE Redmann . Osmotic and specific ion effect on the germination of alfalfa . Can J Bot , 1974 . 52 ( 4 ): 803 - 808 . . Osmotic and specific ion effect on the germination of alfalfa S Rehman , PJC Harris , WF Bourne , J Wilkin . The effect of sodium chloride on germination and the potassium and calcium content of Acacis seeds . Seed Sci Technol , 1996 . 25 ( 1 ): 45 - 57 . . The effect of sodium chloride on germination and the potassium and calcium content of Acacis seeds JB Smithson , JA Thompson , RJ Summerfield . RJ Summerfield , EH Roberts . Chickpea ( Cicer arietinum L.) . Grain Legume Crops , 1985 . : London Collins Publications , 312 - 390 . . Chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.) A Soltani , S Galeshi , E Zeinali , N Latifi . Germination, seed reserve utilization and seedling growth of chickpea as affected by salinity and seed size . Seed Sci Technol , 2002 . 30 ( 1 ): 51 - 60 . . Germination, seed reserve utilization and seedling growth of chickpea as affected by salinity and seed size HD Upadhyaya . Geographical patterns of variation for morphological and agronomic characteristics in the chickpea germplasm collection . Euphytica , 2003 . 132 ( 3 ): 343 - 352 . DOI: 10.1023/A:1025078703640 http://doi.org/10.1023/A:1025078703640 . Geographical patterns of variation for morphological and agronomic characteristics in the chickpea germplasm collection YR Wang , L Yu , ZB Nan , YL Liu . Vigor tests used to rank seed lot quality and predict field emergence in four forage species . Crop Sci , 2004 . 44 ( 2 ): 535 - 541 . . Vigor tests used to rank seed lot quality and predict field emergence in four forage species W Welfare , AR Yeo , TJ Flowers . Effects of salinity and ozone, individually and in combination, on the growth and ion contents of two chickpea ( Cicer arietinum L.) varieties . Environ Pollut , 2002 . 120 ( 2 ): 397 - 403 . 12395854 DOI: 10.1016/S0269-7491(02)00109-4 http://doi.org/10.1016/S0269-7491(02)00109-4 . Effects of salinity and ozone, individually and in combination, on the growth and ion contents of two chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.) varieties K Wignarajah , DH Jennings , JF Handley . Effect of salinity on growth of Phaseolus vulgaris L. II. The effect of internal solute concentration . Ann Bot , 1975 . 39 ( 5 ): 1039 - 1055 . . Effect of salinity on growth of Phaseolus vulgaris L. II. The effect of internal solute concentration HD Yadav , OP Yadav , OP Dhankar , MC Oswal . Effect of chloride salinity and boron on germination, growth and mineral composition of chickpea ( Cicer arientinum L.) . Annals of Arid Zone , 1989 . 28 ( 1 ): 63 - 67 . . Effect of chloride salinity and boron on germination, growth and mineral composition of chickpea (Cicer arientinum L.) BT Yasseen , JA Jurjee , SA Sofaly . Changes in some growth processes induced by NaCl in individual leaves of two barley cultivars . Indian J Plant Physiol , 1987 . 30 ( 1 ): 1 - 6 . . Changes in some growth processes induced by NaCl in individual leaves of two barley cultivars The authors acknowledge the help from Prof. Dr. Sebahattin Ozcan, Department of Field Crops, University of Ankara, Turkey for practical guidance and Mrs. Aysegul Gurbuz, Central Agricultural Research Institute, Ankara, Turkey for providing seeds and protein analyses. 10.1631/jzus.B0720268 2007-11-09 2008-03-31 2022-01-05 Copyright © 2008, Journal of Zhejiang University Science 2008 Journal of Zhejiang University-SCIENCE B (Biomedicine and Biotechnology) 05 09